Jul 13, 2017
Prof. Koller did a great job communicating difficult material in an accessible manner. Thanks to her for starting Coursera and offering this advanced course so that we can all learn...Kudos!!
Oct 23, 2017
The course was deep, and well-taught. This is not a spoon-feeding course like some others. The only downside were some "mechanical" problems (e.g. code submission didn't work for me).
par Ashwin P•
Jan 09, 2017
Great material. Course mentors are nowhere to be found and some of the problems are hard, so I'd have liked to see some guidance.
par Shawn C•
Nov 05, 2016
The course is great with plenty of knowledge. A little defect is about description about assignment. As the forum discussed, several quizzes may confusing.
par Dat N•
Mar 28, 2018
The course helps me understand what a probabilistic graphical model is and how and why it works. One aspect I like the most about the course is the programming assignments. Those PA really make a lot of concepts clearer although sometimes you need to think carefully when the instruction is hard to follow. I think there should be more test case and expected results so that students know what is asked and to evaluate their own code. The instructor is generally clear but sometimes she goes too fast on certain concept. The course is hard but if you gives in time and effort you can complete it.
par Surender K•
Nov 07, 2016
Wonderful course with great material. Wish there were more examples in the material. Nonetheless cannot complain to get this course for free with SEE material and programming assignments (need to complete yet in this session)
par serge s•
Oct 18, 2016
Thanks to this course, Probabilistic Graphical Models are not anymore an esoteric subject! I am really looking for the second part of the course.
par Stephen A•
May 18, 2018
I really enjoyed this course. Prof Koller presents the material very well, and it's really interesting to see how probabilistic graphical model frameworks are underpinned mathematically. I thought it was a pretty tough course at points, and while the lectures are good I found having a copy of Prof Koller's textbook very useful.
I would give this course 5 stars, but I thought some of the programming assignments involved too much grappling with MATLAB rather than illuminating the principles in the lectures. Also, I think the order of the lectures may have been changed since the course was first run as there are occasional references to things that have not been covered at that point.
Overall though, very enjoyable. I'm looking forward to parts 2 and 3.
par Nikesh B•
Nov 06, 2016
Sep 12, 2017
Great intro to probabilistic models
par Péter D•
Oct 29, 2017
great job, although the last PA is a huge pain / difficulty spike - more hints would be nice
par george v•
Jul 07, 2017
very nice intuition from the professor Daphne Koller and "compact" in these lectures that dont exceed 15min each. really glad i did the first one, wish i did also the other two parts, certainly will when i find the time. Just as a comment, i mostly enjoyed the programming assignments. they are very well structured and in a very particular manner, which at the same time is the strong and the weak point of the assingment, since at times i undertsood something else than what the actual implementation was. anyway they were really a challenge, and whoever manages to do them should be glad with his work. Thank you prof. Koller for this course!
Nov 30, 2017
The materials are very interesting, however, this professor speaks so fast that it is hard to grasp the deep theory. In overall, this course is great. And I really need to do the assignment to enhance my comprehension about the content.
par Tianyi X•
Feb 20, 2018
Lack of top-down review of the PGM.
par Alain M•
Nov 03, 2018
Overall very good quality content. PAs are useful but some questions/tests leave too much to interpretation and can be frustrating for students. Audio quality for the classes could also be improved.
par Sunsik K•
Jul 31, 2018
Broad introduction to general issues
par Shantanu B•
Sep 03, 2018
This course is a very essential learning step for people who want to learn and work with Baysean or Markov networks. I think that the course can be further improved by going a little slow on certain assertions or deductions which are fundamental to the subject. Those should be properly emphasized. But overall the assignments were challenging and actually made you think about the things taught in that corresponding video.
Jun 20, 2019
par Soumyadipta D•
Jul 16, 2019
lectures are too fast otherwise great
par Anshuman S•
May 08, 2019
I would recommend adding some supplemental reading material.
par Michel S•
Jul 14, 2018
Good course, but the material really needs a refresh!
par Jonathan K•
Jan 26, 2018
Interesting and useful material, but I found the lecturer unengaging.
par Christos G•
Mar 09, 2018
Quite difficult, not much help in discussion forums, some assignmnents had insufficient supporting material and explanations, challenging overall, I thought at least 3-4 times to abandon it.
par John E M•
Apr 01, 2018
Lectures were OK and quizzes and exams appropriately difficult. But Labs were pretty difficult especially lab 4 which I ended up surrendering on. This means I didn't do the accompanying quiz and gave up on the possibility of honors recognition as well.
While labs don't have to be as hand-holding as the DeepLearning class by Coursera, it would be nice to get more help and maybe not submit errors for the parts I haven't tackled yet when submitting (as DeepLearning and MachineLearning courses figured out how to do).
par Kervin P•
Jan 05, 2017
This is an amazing course, and taught by an extremely talented and accomplished professor. I believe it's a must for anyone in AI/ML or Statistical Inference. The problem is that you're essentially on your own the entire course. There isn't any community or TA help to speak off. And the project is done in Matlab, so you end up wrestling with Matlab or Octave instead of actually doing and learning. I still recommend the course, but that's only because the material is so extremely important.
par Xingjian Z•
Nov 02, 2017
Fun topic. But the explanation of the mentor is somewhat vague and the material is sometimes outdated and misleading.
par Robert M•
Feb 06, 2018
Started off well. Finished poorly