07.04 – Information in a Black Hole

Loading...

En provenance du cours de University of Alberta

Astro 101: Black Holes

84 notes

University of Alberta

Astro 101: Black Holes

84 notes

What is a black hole? Do they really exist? How do they form? How are they related to stars? What would happen if you fell into one? How do you see a black hole if they emit no light? What’s the difference between a black hole and a really dark star? Could a particle accelerator create a black hole? Can a black hole also be a worm hole or a time machine? In Astro 101: Black Holes, you will explore the concepts behind black holes. Using the theme of black holes, you will learn the basic ideas of astronomy, relativity, and quantum physics. After completing this course, you will be able to: • Describe the essential properties of black holes. • Explain recent black hole research using plain language and appropriate analogies. • Compare black holes in popular culture to modern physics to distinguish science fact from science fiction. • Describe the application of fundamental physical concepts including gravity, special and general relativity, and quantum mechanics to reported scientific observations. • Recognize different types of stars and distinguish which stars can potentially become black holes. • Differentiate types of black holes and classify each type as observed or theoretical. • Characterize formation theories associated with each type of black hole. • Identify different ways of detecting black holes, and appropriate technologies associated with each detection method. • Summarize the puzzles facing black hole researchers in modern science.

À partir de la leçon

Inside a Black Hole

What is in a black hole? This module will start to explore the theoretical side of black hole physics. You will receive a basic introduction to relevant topics of Quantum Mechanics and thermodynamics with the aim of understanding current black hole debates among the giants of the field.

07.01 – Black Holes The Final Frontier1:52

07.02 – Introduction to Quantum Mechanics15:25

07.03 – Hawking Radiation6:28

07.04 – Information in a Black Hole7:57

07.05 – Black Hole Thermodynamics11:55

07.06 – Lifespan of a Black Hole10:42

07.07 – Module Summary3:23

Interviews with experts - What is quantum information?1:57

Rencontrer les enseignants

Sharon Morsink
Associate Professor
Department of Physics, University of Alberta

Why are we so concerned about quantum mechanics,

as it relates to black holes?

Well, the existence of Hawking radiation

presents an interesting problem to black hole physicists.

Classical black holes can be characterized by three numbers;

their mass, angular momentum, and charge.

This is a concept called the no-hair theorem which is a way of saying that information,

which is what we mean by hair in this instance,

can't escape from a black hole.

But quantum mechanics tells a completely different story,

which has led to one of the biggest unsolved problems of our time,

the black hole information paradox.

In addition to quantum mechanics enabling processes like Hawking radiation,

it also throws a bit of a wrench into theories that

try to combine quantum mechanics with general relativity.

In particular, quantum mechanics requires information to be preserved.

So in order for astrophysicists to have a complete description of a black hole,

they will have to find a way to explain the so-called black hole information paradox.

Information can be defined as something which is an answer to a question.

When physicists talk about information,

they're generally asking questions about the characteristics and state of something.

So when we ask about the mass of a star,

or we measure what its spectral output is, we're generating information.

Now imagine that you're the commander of a scientific research vessel,

that's in orbit around a black hole,

collecting measurements about the properties of the black hole.

You can very easily deduce the mass of the black hole by observing,

measuring, and timing how long it takes to orbit the black hole at a given distance.

You can also measure the spin of the black hole by comparing the size of

the innermost stable circular orbit to the size of the event horizon.

And by dropping a couple of test charges and observing their behaviour,

you can tell the charge of the black hole.

Scientists think that most black holes have zero charge anyway.

So as the commander,

you've collected all this data,

but oh no you've accidentally crossed the event horizon.

Luckily, you and your crew have survived but the future is bleak.

Given the fuel that you have in your reserve,

you can only postpone your collision with the singularity by a few hours,

maybe a few days at most.

Is there any way that you could send what you learned back to

a distant observer or does the event horizon prevent information from escaping?

Classical physics, that is to say general relativity,

has very bad news for you.

There's no way for you to transmit your data across the event horizon.

But being a good spaceship captain,

you are brushed up on your quantum mechanics and you know about two important principles;

quantum determinism and the principle of reversibility.

Let's start by unpacking the easy one, reversibility.

Reversibility is the idea that physical laws can be used to

predict the future or the past of a particular system.

If we look at a comet shooting by,

not only can we predict where it will be decades from now,

but also where it was decades in the past.

In some sense, reversibility also tells us that we can go

backwards from one state just as well as we can go forwards.

In reality, we know that reversibility is more complex than that.

Shattered mugs don't suddenly unshatter themselves.

But we'll address that when we discuss entropy.

On the other hand,

quantum determinism is a much stranger idea.

Determinism, on its own,

is the idea that we can predict the outcome of

any interaction if we have sufficient information.

If I throw a ball and you know its direction and how fast it's going,

where it lands is predetermined.

But quantum mechanics basically deconstructs the notion of

classical determinism because of a concept called the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle.

Since we have limits on what we can measure,

we also have limits on what we can predict.

Quantum determinism is then telling us a slightly different version of the story.

We can predict with certainty what

the probabilities of outcomes will be in quantum mechanics.

Since the principles of quantum determinism and

reversibility are fundamental to quantum mechanics,

we've run into a problem.

These two principles together mean that information must always be preserved.

But the no-hair theorem for black holes,

says that information falling into

a black hole disappears when it crosses the event horizon.

Many scientists postulate that the information is

destroyed somewhere at the interior of the black hole.

In the next lesson, we'll delve further into this investigation,

examining specific theories which attempt to explain the black hole information paradox.

So, which is it?

Is information preserved by quantum mechanics,

or is it destroyed by general relativity?

There are many possibilities.

The information could be destroyed,

it could leak out of the black hole gradually,

or maybe information could escape in a powerful explosion.

Perhaps the black hole itself saves the information like a giant hard drive.

The sad truth is that we just don't know.

Although there are no known laws that unify

gravitation with quantum mechanics, many researchers,

including Stephen Hawking, now believe that information is preserved

somehow and deeply linked to the process of Hawking radiation.

Some researchers have had other interesting ideas.

One such interesting idea is the concept of a new boundary

within the event horizon, the information firewall.

In 2012, a group of physicists Almheiri,

Marolf, Polchinski and Sully, shortened to AMPS,

introduced the concept of a boundary of high energy quanta

that destroy all incoming information, the AMPS Firewall.

The AMPS Firewall cleans up some of the inconsistencies of quantum mechanics by

providing a mechanism to destroy or scramble the incoming information.

But some scientists think that the firewall creates more problems than it solves.

Present day research, done by Don Page at the University of Alberta,

suggests that the information Firewall described by

the AMPS group could produce a naked singularity.

If indeed there is a firewall within a black hole,

Page and his collaborators demonstrate that the firewall could migrate to a region

outside of the event horizon allowing

the singularity to become visible to distant observers.

We already know how much physicists abhor a naked singularity.

One of Page's research collaborators,

Misao Sasaki, has said if a firewall exists,

not only would an in falling object be destroyed by it,

but the destruction could be visible even from the outside.

This is a very complex idea,

but it brings up an interesting motivation for physicists.

If the firewall idea is right,

it means that there is new physics for us to consider.

If the firewall idea is wrong,

it means that we've uncovered some potential flaws in older physical theories.

Although there is no consensus about how

the black hole information paradox will be resolved,

there are several leading theories about

the fate of information that has fallen into a black hole.

One such theory, put forth by Stephen Hawking

when he originally described Hawking radiation in 1976,

predicts that the outflow particles from

the black hole would have unpredictable properties.

So, then what does Hawking radiation actually look like?

Explorer notre catalogue

Rejoignez-nous gratuitement et obtenez des recommendations, des mises à jour et des offres personnalisées.

Coursera propose un accès universel à la meilleure formation au monde, en partenariat avec des universités et des organisations du plus haut niveau, pour proposer des cours en ligne.

© 2019 Coursera Inc. Tous droits réservés.

Télécharger dans l'App Store

Disponible sur Google Play