Chevron Left
Retour à Stalin and Stalinism in Russian History

Avis et commentaires pour d'étudiants pour Stalin and Stalinism in Russian History par Université HSE

151 évaluations
53 avis

À propos du cours

This online course presents the life and deeds of Joseph Stalin, the leader of the Soviet Union from 1924 till 1953. It discusses the reasons for his actions and their results, as well as the causes of his popularity in Russia today. It offers an analysis of the phenomenon of Stalinism and of its significance for Russia and beyond. In the late 1920s – early 1930s Stalin directed the massive and rapid industrialisation of the country and the forced collectivisation of its agriculture. The industrialisation was based on forced labour, and collectivisation on repression, but both helped to create the material base for the Soviet defence industry. In the late 1930s Stalin unleashed mass terror against the Soviet people, in which millions perished. In his view this helped to rid the country of any potential internal enemies on the eve of the coming war. The USSR, together with its allies, won the Second World War, but at the cost of dozens of millions of lives. Stalin was instrumental in creating the post-war order. The system which he created in the 1930s shaped the USSR as it was during his lifetime and for decades after his death. It also influenced the lives of millions of people beyond the Soviet borders. Stalin and his methods remain popular among significant segments of the Russian population to this day. The course is designed for the beginner level: for all those who want to know more about the history of Russia, particularly in the 20th century. It will enable those who take it to develop an informed understanding of the Stalin era and of the phenomenon of Stalinism. It can be taken independently or as a distance learning supplement to the off-line courses on Soviet history....

Meilleurs avis

12 mars 2019

A great course. A very interesting topic that gives a lot of details. A good course for people interested in history. The assignments at the end of the lecture help to remember all the material.

12 avr. 2019

This was quite detailed. There is so much to be learned from this class. And to think, it all is relatively recent history. Thank you.

Filtrer par :

1 - 25 sur 52 Avis pour Stalin and Stalinism in Russian History

par Arthur R

24 déc. 2017

History from the neo-liberal perspective. Tendentious and lopsided to be point of being comical at times.

par Roberto M R

4 janv. 2020

It is almost impossible to complete this course with so many peer reviews to do and not sufficient peers to review. I have been in this course for half a year and completed all my assignments months and months ago and still have not been able to get a certificate because of the stupid requirements of a lot of peer reviews. Who is the instructor for this course? I think he or she may need to take a class in pedagogy.

par Miguel Á R A

21 juil. 2020

Ausente de criticismo, se enumeran numerosos datos sin ningún fundamento científico y sin respaldo de fuentes. Un curso mediocre.

par Lars G

29 mai 2020

Cool presentation of one of the most important leaders in the 20th century. Irina explains and educate you in a charming un-american way. Recommended!

par Matthew A

22 mars 2018

Very interesting course. Well taught and good materials. Note that coursework relies on weekly mini-essays and a final longer essay.

par Richard T

22 déc. 2020

Interesting subject-matter covered by a good syllabus but, alas, not a university-level course -- not even high school level, not even a course, more like a series of videos unified byba common theme. First, the assessment mechanism is entirely flawed. In a freshman/sophomore level class, it is meaningless to have three students grade another student's essays. A recognized expert needs to do the grading -- someone' whose expertise was garnered from successful post-graduate academic accomplishment in a relevant sphere of studies corresponding to the topical content of the course. There is a gross failure of quality control to have grading driven by students who themselves are neophytes. Moreover, grading rubrics offered are inapt and, as written, poor generic devices to evaluate essays. By the end of the course, from the essays I read, students seemed unable to synthesize knowledge and undertake critical analysis of historical evidence (important intended learning outcomes in a history course). Second, essays are not subject to any kind of plagiarism checking of even the most rudimentary kind; it may be permissible to quote from the lecture material but it is not permissible to cut and paste from the internet without attribution. Third, reading material is not linked to the lectures. Information content in the videos is fairly sparse. I used two books, on my own initiative [Khlevniuk, Stalin; Montefiore, Young Stalin) to supplement the relatively meager information garnered from the lectures. Fourth, the lecturer, while obviously knowledgeable, speaks in English at a slow pace, a speed about half that which is normal, as if it is a English as a foreign language (EFL) class. Obviously, then 12 minutes of her speaking only delivers 6 minutes that a speaker at a normal speach pace would deliver. Better if she would just deliver at normal pace Russian (her native language) and simply provide a transcript in English scrolling down as she speaks. Fifth, the assessment mechanism focuses on an essay, at the end of every unit, that until the last and second-to-last essay, requires only regurgitation of lecture content. The last two essays are more profound requiring research content but, alas, both are due at the same time and there is no time do valuable research. Worse, I noticed that students submitted essays, for these two items, wholly irrelevant to the topic stipulated by the instructor; those in question clearly did not understand the question yet Coursera then "employs" them, as a course requirement, to grade others' submissions? To say the least, this is really problematic.

par Stephen B

27 nov. 2017

A very interesting review of recent Russian and Soviet history, offering a good insight into the person and the times that created it and influenced much of Russian society today. The lectures are easy to follow and nicely descriptive. The weekly essays, required for completion of the course, were thought-provoking, and the range of ideas and perspectives presented in the student essays (peer review of which also is required) was very interesting, too.There were only a few minor problems; for example, sometimes the script for each lecture, which is provided below the lecture video area, wasn't correct because of mistyping or misunderstanding of what was spoken. Also, in a couple of cases, the peer-review forms had rating sections that were confusing or not exactly correct for the specific essay being reviewed. But overall, it was an excellent course, presented in a balanced and professional way.

par David H

20 mars 2020

I found this course very interesting and taught in an easy to learn manner. Right from lesson one it followed a chronological order and explained how all the different people and events combined. I learned much more than I ever thought I would and recommend it to anyone in interests to learn more.

par Maria C É Á

3 janv. 2019

Excellent course ! I've enrolled in several Coursera Courses and this is one of the best. Professor Filatova has designed a clear and wide syllabus, the issues are well fundamented and it "opens space" for further research. Good study materials and presentation on the whole. Clara Águas

par Miguel V

22 sept. 2017

The best course to understand the Russian History for 20th Century.

Really nice and interesting video lectures for each chapter.

I really like the friendly atmosphere form other students who check your weekly "homework".

100% recommend.

par Irina B

13 mars 2019

A great course. A very interesting topic that gives a lot of details. A good course for people interested in history. The assignments at the end of the lecture help to remember all the material.

par Nancy K

12 avr. 2019

This was quite detailed. There is so much to be learned from this class. And to think, it all is relatively recent history. Thank you.

par Yuka I

5 janv. 2019

Excellent course. Very well prepared, the talk of lecturer is interesting, the content itself is intriguing.

par María F

30 août 2021

Muy completo. El conocimiento y la narración de la profesora es muy bueno.


12 août 2020

An interesting, well-built course. I thoroughly enjoyed it.

par celestial c

23 févr. 2018

Very Good course to supplement study of Soviet history!

par M D

3 mai 2021

Excellent course that delves deeply into Stalin and Russian history. Initially I thought the instructor video was a bit dry, however she presents very intelligently and the excellent accompanying PowerPoint complemented the instructor. Reviewing peers work reinforced my learning. This course is a time investment, but I was disappointed when it ended. Highly recommend if you're interested in subject matter. Also very interesting discussion of propaganda with images followed by photos of what was occurring.

par Kathy C

5 oct. 2021

What a great course! So very interesting, I learned a lot.

I've found the global trend to authoritarianism to be disturbing, particularly (of course) now that it's reached the USA. As a result, I've been studying History, both of the USA and global. This is one of the most interesting History courses I've taken, and I liked the format with the pictures, etc.

D​ear Professor and HSE University, please do more courses like this!

par Marcy H

11 janv. 2018

Excellent course -- very informative, directed us to a lot of external resources. I also enjoyed the professor's presentation. The topics she presented most of the time were certainly not jovial and her presentation reflected the seriousness with which she treated the topics.

I recommend this course to anyone interested in Russian history, or this period in either western or eastern European history.

par D L Z

5 sept. 2018

This is one of the best courses that I have taken on Coursera. I really learned a lot! It is very well presented and the system of writing something every week is a great learning tool. Excellent Professor. Very proficient mentor, too. Thank you very much for the opportunity to learn so much about Stalin and Soviet life.

par George H H

15 févr. 2021

This course is interesting, thought provoking and immensely interesting. The Professor's presentations were stimulating and gave an insightful view of Russian History during a world changing period. I really enjoyed this course and would recommend it wholeheartedly. Thank you Professor Filatova.

par Weronika K

21 oct. 2017

Very informative and objective account of Stalinism with wide background (from Lenin till today) allowing to see "the bigger picture". Highly recommended for anybody interested in 20th century history and/or trying to understand Russia and Soviet Union.

par DragonBarView S T

17 nov. 2017

An excellent introduction to one of the most important figures of the 20th century. Clearly and simply presented this course encourages the student to find out more. The assignments were challenging and thought-provoking.

par Christopher S

6 sept. 2020

I took this course purely for the pleasure of learning more about this fascinating subject. Although I did not participate in the peer-graded elements, I enjoyed te lectures and video classes immensely. Thank you.